¡Uno! ¡Dos! ¡Tré! Or: Do you have the time, to listen to Green Day whine (on a triple-album)?

Power-pop rockers Green Day are releasing a trilogy of albums from September 2012.   Triple releases are rare for popular artists and usually are live recordings or greatest hits compilations.

Green Day: you know, Uno?

But can Green Day pull it off?  Will it be any good?  Will it sell?  And will anybody care?

Critical reception

There have been a number of multi-album releases by comparable artists in recent times, think the Foo Fighters (In Your Honor), the Red Hot Chili Peppers (Stadium Arcadium) and Metallica (Load/ReLoad).  Although they have performed solidly, they have invariably been less strongly received in comparison to the rest of their career.

Multi-album releases such as these by popular artists typically contain strong singles; however inevitably receive a lukewarm reception as albums.  Common criticisms include a lack of quality control, and over-indulgence.

Even some of the most critically acclaimed multi-LPs suffer from filler – think Turd on the Run and I Just Want to See His Face from Exile on Mainstreet and Wild Honey Pie and Revoultion 9 from the White Album.

Just because the band thinks it’s good, it doesn’t mean it should be released.

Selling the album format

It has been well documented that the popularity of album format is declining.  Particularly as platforms like iTunes, Spotify and YouTube have made it easy, and cheaper, to consume singles.

The popularity of these formats suggests that fickle and time-poor music fans simply don’t have the time or desire to sit through albums in the way they used to.  Rather, they create their own mixtapes and playlists, which typically comprise singles spanning genres, eras and artists.

Green Day: After 20 years, what more can they say?

Will Green Day’s trilogy of 3 full priced, power-pop studio albums sell?  Sure Green Day’s loyal supporter base might buy them all – but most consumers will pick and choose the singles they want to add to their playlist in the same way they would songs from a traditional LP.
What will it be about?

Finally, what more does Green Day have to say?  After covering masturbation, teen-angst, the drudgery of middle-class life and a shot a political dialogue – do we need another 30+ songs?

At least if it all goes pear-shaped, they could just re-release and tour Dookie.

// Alec Schumann

* I haven’t forgotten the rare cases where multi-disc releases are considered among an artists’ best work (think Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds, Tom Waits and George Harrison, etc.)

About AnthonySchumann
Subtle Bravado // Creative Boutique. Ted Anthony - Vision Alec Schumann - Creative Follow @AnthonySchumann

2 Responses to ¡Uno! ¡Dos! ¡Tré! Or: Do you have the time, to listen to Green Day whine (on a triple-album)?

  1. GD Chords says:

    To answer your questions…

    But can Green Day pull it off? – Yes!

    Will it be any good? – Yes, I bet you $5

    Will it sell? – Well, I’m going to buy it…so yes!

    And will anybody care? – Heck yes!


  2. Jack says:

    psh, of course it will sell! Just because skeptics like YOU (author) wouldn’t buy it, doesn’t mean REAL fans won’t!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: